top of page

What Is Watchful Waiting in Gender Care? A Sourced Guide for Families

TransHealthHub
Oct 7
4 min read

Key Takeaways

  • What is watchful waiting in gender care? An approach for children before puberty: clinicians support and observe a child's gender expression, generally holding off on a full social transition until early puberty.

  • The model was designed at a gender clinic in Amsterdam and does not try to change a child's gender identity.

  • No medication is involved; the Endocrine Society recommends against it before puberty.

  • The approach drew on research about "desistance," a body of studies that a 2022 review rated as poor quality.

  • In a U.S. and Canadian study of 317 transgender youth followed about five years after a social transition, 94 percent identified as binary transgender youth.


The short answer

Watchful waiting is a clinical approach for gender-diverse children before puberty. The care team and family let the child express their gender freely and follow how their identity develops, but generally wait until early puberty before a full social transition, such as a new name and pronouns. It involves no medication and does not try to change who the child is.


At TransHealthHub, we explain approaches families may hear about. Our page on support without medical steps covers care for younger children.


Where the approach came from

The model began in the Netherlands. Diane Ehrensaft, of the University of California, San Francisco, wrote in 2017 that the model was designed by the interdisciplinary team at the Amsterdam Center of Expertise on Gender Dysphoria.


"In children with gender dysphoria only, the general recommendation is watchful waiting and carefully observing how gender dysphoria develops in the first stages of puberty," Annelou de Vries and Peggy Cohen-Kettenis said in a 2012 description of that clinic's approach. Gender dysphoria means distress when gender identity differs from sex assigned at birth. Their account describes one Dutch clinic's protocol at the time, not current U.S. standards.


How it works in practice

Under this model, a child's gender expression "is not to be manipulated in any way, but observed over time," Ehrensaft said. Children have safe spaces to express their gender, and the clinical team checks that they are growing well and getting their emotional needs met.


The model holds off on a full social transition until puberty. Ehrensaft said the reasoning was that early puberty could help a child determine which gender feels most authentic. Our guide to social transition explains what that step involves.


How it compares with the gender affirmative model

The main difference is timing. Ehrensaft said the gender affirmative model "parts ways with the watchful waiting model" in "the waiting part."


Watchful waiting

Gender affirmative model

Who it is for

Children before puberty

Children and adolescents

Child's gender expression

Supported and observed over time

Supported, with the child describing their own identity

Social transition

Generally held until early puberty

Considered at any age, case by case

Medication before puberty

None

None

Attempts to change identity

No

No

For young children, the Endocrine Society's 2017 guideline says social transition decisions are made with the assistance of a mental health professional or another experienced professional.


The research behind the model

The model relied on data about "persisters" and "desisters," Ehrensaft said. Those terms describe children whose gender identity did or did not continue into adolescence.


A 2022 systematic review by Baer Karrington in Transgender Health examined 35 items on this topic. Its five quantitative studies, covering 251 participants, were all rated poor quality, and the review found 30 different definitions of desistance. Karrington said the term "should no longer be used in clinical work or research." Low-quality evidence on this question is not evidence that any approach causes harm.


Newer data come from Kristina Olson and colleagues, who followed 317 transgender youth in the U.S. and Canada (average age 8.1 at the start) an average of about five years after an early social transition. In their 2022 Pediatrics study, 94 percent identified as binary transgender youth, 3.5 percent as nonbinary, and 2.5 percent as cisgender. The authors said the results "suggest that retransitions are infrequent." The families were community-recruited and supportive, and there was no comparison group.


Leading U.S. medical groups, including the American Medical Association, American Academy of Pediatrics, American Psychological Association, and the Endocrine Society, regard this care as evidence-based and medically necessary.


How it differs from the 2025 federal report

Families may also hear about exploratory therapy, a different approach promoted in a 2025 U.S. Department of Health and Human Services report. KFF said the report's view of the risks of medical care marks a departure from most medical associations and widely used U.S. guidelines, and that it promotes therapeutic approaches, including "exploratory therapy," as first-line treatment.


The Endocrine Society said in May 2024 that its guideline takes "a very conservative approach to care, with no medical intervention prior to puberty." Our page on whether a teen is too young to know addresses a common parent worry.


Frequently asked questions

Does watchful waiting mean doing nothing? No. The child is supported and followed by a clinical team.

Does watchful waiting apply to teenagers? It was designed for younger children. Once puberty begins, a separate assessment applies; our page on Tanner stages explains the timing.

Is watchful waiting the same as conversion therapy? No. As Ehrensaft described it, the model makes no attempt to alter a child's gender identity or expression.


Further Reading and Resources


This page addresses a health topic and reflects the evidence as of October 2026. It is not medical advice. Decisions about a young person's care belong to that young person, their family, and their clinicians.

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
  • Youtube
  • X
  • Facebook
  • Instagram

If you are in crisis or thinking about suicide, help is available right now.

Call or text 988 (the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline).

​​​​​

© 2026 TransHealthHub

bottom of page